Cash In For Success: Lesson 2

I know this looks strange posting Lesson 2 after Lesson 3, but there is a reason... I forgot to post Lesson 2! These articles have appeared in the Creative Finance & Management eZine in the right sequence. I usually post the articles on the blog a few days after the newsletter goes out, but in this case I forgot. Oops! Sorry.

Lesson two is all about doing what you can to minimise the risk of non-payment by your customers - doing credit checks and setting credit limits.

I suppose the first thing you can do is to not give credit at all! I don't see why small companies should be funding bigger companies (presuming that's who your customers are). If you have already paid for goods and services in providing your product/service to your customer, why should you have to wait any longer to recoup that spending? So, if you can, get cash up front (especially if you are providing a service) or cash on delivery.

What you are trying to do here is minimise your exposure. You are exposed if you have provided valuable products or services to your customer/client, but have not yet received payment. It's an exposure to potential loss, because if they don't pay you then you will have given away something valuable for nothing.

So what do you do if you can't get cash up front or on delivery? Well you will want your exposure to be as small as possible without restricting trading too much.

The two tools you have to help you to keep your exposure as small as possible are credit limits and credit terms. Many small businesses don't use these tools, because they either don't know how to set them, or they think they will lose business if they set them. But just think how much you would lose if you have given a big credit limit (or none at all) and generous payment terms to someone you thought would be a good customer, and then they go bust after maxing their limit. How much would the loss be? Much more than you would lose by limiting their spending power with you.

But how do you decide on credit terms and credit limits? Should you have standard terms and limits? The answer to that question is varying degrees of "no"!

Credit terms are more likely to be standard than limits. Find out what competitors and other players in your industry give. You will then have some idea of what your customers will be used to. But even then you shouldn't feel like you have to stick with those in every case. So if the standard in the industry, or for that type of product/service, seems to be 45 days or 60 days, it's perfectly fine to try for 15 or 30 days. The smaller the term, the less your exposure will be. You can, perhaps, justify this by saying, "I know that other companies will give you 60 days credit, but we're just a small company and we can't afford to be giving customers that long. And remember the reason we are better is that we are smaller and more responsive [i.e. this is another opportunity to plug your USP]."

But, having made that last point, NEVER do the reverse and use generous credit terms as a selling point. "Choose us, we let you take longer to pay!" You are obviously getting desperate if you have to do that! What you are really saying if you do this is, "I know it looks like we are selling widgets, but really we want to be your bank!" You are NOT in the business to lend your customers money, so get them used to paying you as soon as you reasonably can. And also just think about what kind of customers it will attract - the ones who are desperate for credit and therefore more likely to go bust and not pay you, or more likely to try to pay late every time as well. Not the kind of customers you want!

What about credit limits? This is more difficult. And I haven't got space to talk about it this time, so it will have to wait until next time. Sorry.

So in two weeks we will have a think about how you would go about setting credit limits.

In the meantime see if you can find a shortlist of companies, local and national, that can provide credit checking reports.

All the best!

Cash In For Success: Lesson 3

By Edwina Taylor

Despite the UK Government's interventions and the succession of recent interest rate reductions, there seems little sign of a mellowing in the commercial banks' attitude to lending to businesses. Forecasts claim that it will be 2011 before any meaningful return of confidence in the banking system. If access to external finance remains difficult to obtain, businesses will need to be vigilant in their management of working capital during 2010. All reasonable care needs to be taken in the management of trade credit.

Sound credit management can minimise the risk of a business being landed with bad debts. Obviously that risk can never be completely eliminated, even in benign trading conditions, but in these cautious times, the aim of the exercise must be to ensure that the credit offered reflects the clients' ability to repay it.

SME's must consider taking elementary steps to protect against the risk of bad or late debts, so: -

• Consider what methods of payment you are happy to accept from customers. Retail businesses in particular need to be flexible here, but credit & debit card systems offer protection to the seller, which is less affected by subsequent changes in the customer's circumstances.
• For non-retail transactions, consider setting a threshold beyond which an extension of credit will be conditional upon a satisfactory credit reference check.
• Decide in advance what your firm's policy is to be with regard to late payments. Many firms incorporate interest clauses in their payment terms, but regardless of whether you do this, any business in the UK is entitled to charge statutory interest, currently set at 8%.
• Ensure that all invoices are sent out promptly, with the name and address of the business clearly and accurately stated along with your payment terms. Many firms believe that charging interest on late payments acts as a further incentive to customers to pay promptly.
• Keep an eye on outstanding invoices and chase debtors if payments do not arrive when expected.

What if payment is not forthcoming?

• Send a letter to the debtor, stating or implying the consequences of a continuing failure to pay. You can always use a solicitor to write on your behalf, but there will then be further costs incurred.
• You could sell your invoices to a factoring company or approach a debt recovery firm to chase the debt for you. This will relieve you of the work of pursuing your debtors, but will have costs attributable to the collection.
• Court action can recover debts. In the UK, for debts of up to £15k you will go through the County Court who will allocate the claim to one of three different streams, including the small claims stream. You may be able to recover collection costs if you win.
• If all else fails, then, for debts over £750, an unpaid creditor can initiate formal insolvency action.

Chasing Payments

Most businesses have heard the old chestnuts: - "the cheque is in the post", and "may I have a copy invoice". These are generally delaying tactics, but don't let it rest, and don't be afraid to insist on immediate payment.

Be diligent with processes - follow through the system of chasing debts, perhaps using a similar pattern as follows:-

Courtesy call the customer enquiring as to whether there is a reason for payment not being made;

Deal with any disputes on the order - asking for payment of those items that are not disputed, advising that the disputed items will be sorted out;

Where there is a cash flow problem agree a payment structure;

Keep records of all conversations and correspondence, email, fax, letters;

If all else fails put the company on STOP until you have been paid.

Remember unpaid bills are a way of easing your customers' cash flow problems at the expense of yours.

Credit Where Credit Is Due

Customers are the lifeblood of any business, but it is worth remembering "a sale is not a sale until it has been paid for". Extending credit is always risky and any business is taking a chance of not being paid, ultimately resulting in loss of profit, valuable time wasted in chasing the debt, and unwanted expense in taking legal action, only to be left with the bill being left unpaid.

Extending credit is like lending customers your own money. Would you advance a cash loan to a complete stranger? I guess your answer is no, but that is exactly what you are doing when you provide goods or services on credit.

Credit checking is widely used, but is it being used correctly? How do you evaluate how safe a business is?

Do you really understand the credit report?

Do you scrutinise the figures or just merely check that there has been no recent adverse activity?

Do you have a financial expert analyse the report?

Do you take up trade references?

Do you offer every customer the same credit terms?

Do you talk to the customer's Bank?

Do you check out the Directors' personal credit ratings?

If you have answered NO to one or more of the above, your business may be at risk. Risk Assessment has become the way forward. Most businesses carry out some enquiries, but the majority are insufficient.

Remember Turnover is Vanity, Profit Is Sanity, Cash Is King

Taking the risk out of extending credit is a vitally important and prudent move to adopt. See our 10 tips to help limit the risk of advancing credit accounts: -

1) Conduct a credit report for each new customer preferably backed up with a financial analysis;

2) Ensure that you ask for 3 trade creditor references and take them up;

3) Ensure you ask for a Bank Reference and that you speak to the bank;

4) Obtain an annual credit report for all customers;

5) Review all customer credit limits annually and do not be afraid to amend the terms or limits;

6) Have clear credit control policies which are "cast in stone" irrespective of the customer;

7) Include a Retention of Title (ROT) clause in your terms and conditions. It can be worth having a Solicitor draw it up for your own protection;

8) If you are supplying a Limited Company, consider obtaining a Personal Guarantee (PG) which will afford protection and allow a claim to be made against the Directors personally if the company folds;

9) Set the credit limit YOU are comfortable with not what the customer is asking for. For orders in excess of the credit limit the balance may be paid for COD or prior to delivery;

10) Ensure customers understand your credit terms and get them to sign the terms and conditions confirming their agreement.

Before you open a credit account be absolutely certain that your company understands your customer's payment system. Some companies will not allow payments to you until you are established on their system. Some companies insist on 90 day payment terms. Be sure that you agree in writing with your customer that payment is to be on your terms, not theirs. It is worth noting the day your customer runs the "cheque run" especially larger companies, government departments, Councils etc. Many only have one "cheque run" each month. You must ensure invoices are sent at least 1 week in advance of this date.

How can Frost Risk Services Help?

With our help, you can:

• Know who you are doing business with;
• Find out who controls that business;
• Review their financial situation;
• Check their credit-worthiness.

You can check the credit status of any business online with Frost Credit Checking 24 hours a day - See www.frostcreditservices.com - It's easy to use, updated daily, and comes with a solvency assessment written by a licensed Insolvency Practitioner if required. Whatever your interest in a business, we can give you bespoke reports and solvency assessments. We'll look at your options and help protect your interests, if need be.

For further information on this or any other debt related matter please call Edwina Taylor on 0845 260 0101 or 07515 334 251. Email edwinat@frostbr.co.uk

www.frostbr.co.uk Offices in Croydon, Dorset,Manchester, London

This is number 7 in an 8-part series especially for new subscribers to Creative Finance & Management. Every week we are sending you an article aimed at helping you to think about a different aspect of the financial management of your business. This is in addition to the normal bi-weekly newsletter. We are doing it to give all new subscribers the same orientation to the way that Charis FD thinks about small business performance management. That way we can have confidence that all our subscribers have been given the benefit of foundational advice in all aspects of business performance management.

If you miss any of these articles, don't worry. They are on the Creative Finance & Management blog. Just look for the "New_Subscribers" tag.

These are the articles in the New Subscribers series:

1. The ingredients for success in Finance
2. Strategy and Planning
3. Business Change - implementing your strategic plans
4. Measurement and Management go together
5. Paralysis without analysis
6. Your Finance team - a valued asset
7. Stakeholder management - the importance of keeping people happy
8. Internal Control - 3 fallacies that add risk to your business

Here we go again: ...

---

Stakeholder management - the importance of keeping people happy

You already know this in all probability, so I will try not to labour the point, but there are many relationships involved in running your business. A lot of them you could call stakeholders. Stakeholders are people or entities that have an interest in your business.

The term is used really to make it clear that businesses do not just exist for shareholders - those who own the business. There are other people and organisations that are affected by and/or interested in the success of the business. They can also affect the success of the business, and you need them on board to help you achieve your vision. So they should be given some attention as well.

If you want examples, stakeholders would be the likes of: customers, suppliers, shareholders, lenders, bankers, employees, local residents, landlords, insurance agents, recruitment agencies, HMRC, pensions providers, auditors, tax advisors, corporate finance advisors, company secretary, non-executive directors, other board members, (maybe the media, your competitors and industry regulators could be others).

Here is another area where you need to be intentional and analytical. Relationships need to be managed. You can't leave them to chance. If you are not managing these relationships right now, why not? Is it because you don't like others interfering in your business? If that's the reason then here's my suggestion for a mindset change - why not see these stakeholders as your teammates, with different skills, abilities, expertise, network contacts, access to funds, wanting your business to succeed and ready to help? Twenty heads are better than one?

And when I say that relationships need to be managed intentionally, I am not saying that you have to be on the phone every week to every single person you identify as a stakeholder. But you have decide intentionally whether you are going to give them any attention and if so, how much and of what sort.

So here's what I think you should do now:

First, brainstorm a list of the stakeholders in your business (and I mean each one, not each category - so each customer and each supplier). Then, for each person or organisation, make a note of:

What do they get out of your business?

Why is your business important to them?

How would you classify their relationship with you (customer, supplier, advisor, investor, etc)? There could be more than one answer.

What do you and your business get out of them?

What else could you get out of them?

How important is this relationship to the success of your business (rate 1 to 10 or High, Medium, Low)?

What is likely to happen if they didn't like you (and on a scale of 1-10 how disastrous would that be for the business)?

What could happen if they liked you more?

How good is your relationship with them (1-10)?

Given the importance of the relationship noted above, how good should your relationship be (1-10)?

What is your relationship strategy for this person or organization (actively develop, regular update on business, mine for leads, no proactive management, etc)?

Finally, there are some stakeholders that are so important that they need extra special attention. Those would be shareholders, customers, lenders, employees, (perhaps some key suppliers and contractors), landlords, bankers and auditors. If they withdrew their funds or their services, or published an adverse comment about your business, you would be stuffed! Perhaps it's worth thinking whether a little bit of extra effort on your part might keep them happy. Perhaps you could give them a little more information than they request, or phone them with an update when they haven't asked, beat deadlines, offer a tour of your facilities, etc. Some things don't cost anything, but they buy lots of goodwill. You never know when you may need them to be understanding!

The next CF&M new subscriber newsletter is the last one, and we'll be looking at internal control - 3 fallacies that add risk to your business.

---

See you then...

If at any stage you want to talk to us, we're quite happy to give you a call to talk more about your business and the challenges you face. And you may be eligible for a free Finance Strategy Review session. To set that up either email us at enquiries@charisfd.com, remembering to leave your phone number and email address; or go to our website and complete the contact form.

Thanks again for subscribing to Creative Finance & Management. We hope you find it helpful.

© Charis Business Consulting Limited 2009