What Information Do We Need to Ensure the Business is Successful?

If you are going to be successful in managing your business, you need measurement. You need facts that tell you how well you are doing and where you need to improve. And those measures of success are much broader than just financial measures, such as profit, cash, margins, etc, however important they are.

How do you make sure that your business is heading in the right direction? How do you make sure that your strategies are working? How can you even tell if your strategies are being implemented effectively? Is profit the only measure of success? Does profit tell you anything about whether you are achieving your vision?

Let's say my vision was to become number 1 in a particular market. How would I know how close I was to achieving that? Not by looking at my profit in isolation. And just asking that question leads to other useful questions that clarify what I am aiming at. For instance, what does becoming number 1 mean? Number 1 for sales volume, turnover, profitability, customer satisfaction? Best company to work for? Most environmentally friendly company in the market? Another question would be, who are my competitors? How do I measure their position or performance? How can I get reliable information about them that will tell me whether I am number 1 or not?

And I should also have strategies to follow that will help me to achieve the vision. So, in this example, I may decide that I am going to offer the best prices in the market in order to win market share. Nothing in my financial statements will tell me whether I am offering the best prices in the market, or whether I am winning market share. And yet if I have set that strategy to achieve my vision, it will be critically important to measure whether it is succeeding.

Other things are also important to measure, things that you need to be doing well in to achieve your vision and succeed in your strategies. For example, customer satisfaction, employee engagement, risk/compliance and corporate social responsibility.

I think my point is made by now, though it may sound strange for a finance guy to say that financial performance is not everything! The point is that even if profits and cash are ultimately what you want to maximize, you have to measure other things that help you get there.

The classic way of doing this is by using a Balanced Business Scorecard. We have not got the space to go into the theory and talk about Kaplan and Norton, who invented the concept. The point I want to get across is that if you want to measure the performance and the success of your business, you have to measure a balanced range of aspects. And you have to decide what those are, depending on what your business, your vision and your strategies are.

A few things I've learned about good balanced scorecards over the years are:

The measures must consistently and explicitly link to your vision and strategy. It's no use measuring things that are not important to that, because measurement and reporting takes time and effort. So you ought to focus on the things that matter.

Keep it simple and focused. Too many measures, even if they are all relevant, will just make it too confusing to interpret, too costly and time-consuming to report on, and will cloud your decision making.

It doesn't all have to be done with numbers. Again, strange for a finance guy to say! But it's true. Sometimes, something as simple as a traffic light measure can be all you need to see if a particular factor is ok, not ok or needs some corrective action.

Use measures as both lead and lag indicators. Lag indicators tell you how you have done. Lead indicators tell you how things might work out. For example, employee engagement can be seen as how your employees were feeling when they did the survey (a lag indicator), but engagement can affect attrition and motivation in the future. So low employee engagement can be seen as a lead indicator to attrition (and therefore higher cost) and low motivation (again, higher cost and potentially higher error rates, which may affect customer service, and so on).

I once worked with a division of a big bank that had a balanced scorecard. We produced it monthly. But it had so many pages in it that it took almost four weeks to produce, only a couple of people in the management team read it all and it was impossible to review in monthly management meetings. So we revamped it, cutting it down by 50%, keeping only the measures that directly related to strategies. We also made the reporting more colourful. Sounds cosmetic, but it actually made it much quicker to read and digest. You could just look at it and focus on the red items, where attention was needed. It then also took half the time to produce every month. The effect of that was to give management more time to review the report, and more time for the Finance department to investigate some of the items further. In turn that led to more efficient and effective decision making in the monthly management meetings, and led to a more successful business.

If you don't use a balanced scorecard to manage your business, I would encourage you to think about it. It doesn't have to be huge and complex. Just think about all the different things that are important to your success, and try to find ways to regularly measure them and report on them.

© Charis Business Consulting Limited 2009

The Importance of Regular Review

The Importance of Regularly Reviewing Your Finances

I was reminded the other day that many smaller businesses struggle
with knowing what financial information they should be looking at
on a regular basis. Some don't look at any financial information,
apart from maybe their bank statement, from one year to the next.
It's kind of a surprise once a year when the accountant takes their
plastic bag of receipts (or perhaps these days a memory stick might
go with the plastic bag!) and two weeks later they sit with their
accountant to find out how they did. Those in that position lack
confidence in whether they have enough money to spend on things for
the business, and they don't know whether they can do things better.

Other owners of smaller businesses lack confidence that they are
looking at the right things on a regular basis.

So here's a simple little checklist to allow you to healthcheck
what information you are looking at on a regular basis. Apologies
to those for whom this is stating the obvious.

First, you need to place priority on keeping the accounts up to
date on a daily basis or weekly basis at the least. If the
information in the accounting system isn't up to date, then the
reports you get out won't be up to date either. So you need your
bookkeeper, accountant, accounts clerks - whoever keeps your
accounts - to regularly post invoices (sales and purchases), bank
receipts and payments on your accounting system.

Second, you need to look at a profit and loss statement every
month, at least. A profit and loss statement (accountants tend to
call it a "P&L") shows your income/revenue and costs in the last
period. One minus the other is your profit or loss for the period.
The reason you look at it as a statement is that it can tell you
many interesting and useful things that you need to know.

For example, you may get a big surprise when you see your gross
margins (gross profit as a percentage of sales revenue) are 40% and
not 60% as you thought. So it prompts you to find out what's going
wrong there. Or you didn't know that someone had ordered a
particular thing and it's cost £1000, so you go and ask them why
they needed it and why they ordered it without telling you. You
can't leave these discoveries until the end of the year!

Just one quick note, because it's not obvious to everyone - make
sure that these monthly P&Ls are done on an "accruals basis". Say
that to your accountant or bookkeeper and they will know what you
mean. The accruals basis really just smoothes out lumpy expenditure
that you pay for in one month, but relates to a different month or
more than one month - so your audit fee that relates to last year,
or your insurance that relates to every month of next year, and so
on.

Third, you need to look also at a balance sheet every month as
well. The balance sheet is just a statement showing what you own,
what you owe and what is owed to you. Looking at it every month
will help you to see trends and start to understand how to manage
your cash better. It'll give you early warning of things going
wrong with your customer accounts, your stock management or bank
accounts.

Fourth, if you are not in a cash or retail business, and your
customers normally get invoices and pay later, then you will need
to keep a careful eye on who owes you what and when it is due. So
get yourself a detailed aged debtors list (aged just means it shows
the amounts owed in age categories depending whether they are
current, overdue, very overdue or extremely overdue). I would
advise looking at the aged debtors list on a weekly basis, and
keeping it on your desk. Know absolutely what is due in the next
week and keep asking your accounts people every day whether it has
arrived. This is the foundation of good credit control, and is
critical to making sure you keep enough cash in the business.

Lastly, for now, you need to think about what other information
would be useful on a daily, weekly and monthly basis. Perhaps you
need to track your sales, revenues, order volumes, gross profits,
production quantities or whatever - the point of getting regular
information on how the business is doing is so that you know about
problems and successes as soon as they occur (and not a year
later!).

Remember, trying to manage the performance of a business without
using regular information is like an athlete trying to improve his
performance without timing himself.

---

Charis FD is Your Friend in Finance. We help businesses with turnover roughly between £1m and £25m, that have not completely got to grips with the finances. Perhaps they are not making enough money, not generating enough cash, or perhaps the finances are simply disorganised and chaotic. We work with the directors and owners in a flexible and affordable way to take the pain out of managing the finances, so that the business can make more money and be even more successful than it already is.

We work mainly in Hampshire, Thames Valley and Central London at the moment.

If any of the above rings true for your business, we would like to hear from you. Either email us at enquiries@charisfd.com, telling us a bit about your business and your finance challenges, or go to our website www.charisfd.com. On our website you will find lots of information, and also a contact form to get in touch with us.

---

That's it for this time.

If you have something that you would like us to write about that would help you in improving the finances of your small business, please let us know...

newsletter@charisfd.com

© Charis Business Consulting Limited 2009

This is the fifth in an 8-part series especially for new subscribers to the Creative Finance & Management email newsletter. Every week we are sending you an article aimed at helping you to think about a different aspect of the financial management of your business. This is in addition to the normal bi-weekly newsletter. We are doing it to give all new subscribers the same orientation to the way that Charis FD thinks about small business performance management. That way we can have confidence that all our subscribers have been given the benefit of foundational advice in all aspects of business performance management.

If you miss any of these articles, don't worry. They are on the Creative Finance & Management blog. Just look for the "New_Subscribers" tag.

These are the articles in the New Subscribers series:

1. The ingredients for success in Finance
2. Strategy and Planning
3. Business Change - implementing your strategic plans
4. Measurement and Management go together
5. Paralysis without analysis
6. Your Finance team - a valued asset
7. Stakeholder management - the importance of keeping people happy
8. Internal Control - 3 fallacies that add risk to your business

Here we go: ...

---

Paralysis without Analysis

Over the last three articles that we've sent to you as part of our new subscriber series we've covered the points around the outside of the business performance management wheel - strategy, change, and performance measurement/reporting. There is one more thing to talk about briefly before moving on to talk about the Finance function (next time) and then other key concerns such as risk, controls and stakeholders. That is performance analysis. I like to call it performance improvement analysis.

If you've read the previous articles in the series you will have picked up the philosophy underlying my advice - be intentional and analytical. Mostly, though, we've talked about being intentional - if you mean business, then you are intentional, you know where you want the business to get to and you know how you intend to get there. And you know whether you are making progress because you are intentional about measuring performance.

Now I want to talk about being analytical.

I started writing something a bit philosophical here at first, and then I heard myself yawn! So I deleted that. Do you want to get under the skin of the performance of your business? Do you see things that are happening and wonder why? Do you wonder which of your products is really the best? Is it the one that sells the most? Do you wonder which of your customers is really the most important? Is it the one that buys the most?

Analysis is all about asking "why?" And "what if?" It can be as basic as "why have we made a loss this month?" Or it could be more complex, such as, "what if we offered early payment discounts of x%?" Or even more complex, like, "what if we paid £xmillion to buy a business?"

It doesn't have to be financial data. Other numerical analysis is useful too. In fact, if you can make it numerical or financial then it is often easier to get a qualitative understanding of the issue - i.e. is it good, bad or ok. One example of numerical analysis that I dealt with in one large group was looking at absenteeism. How many days of work did we lose through sickness? And in which locations? Which teams? Was it seasonal? Was it improving or getting worse? You may be asking, "where is the why question in that?" Well, think about, "why are our staff costs so high?" There are accepted benchmarks around, so we could tell whether the sickness absence rates were better or worse than the average for those types of people. That enabled us to focus on particular areas, ask further questions and put actions in place to improve. Reducing absenteeism eventually led to lower staff costs, because we didn't need as many people to do the work. That's another example of what we saw last time - that measurement enables you to manage and therefore improve.

Analysis enables you to drill right down to cause and effect relationships. The idea is that if you can measure and manage those cause and effect relationships then you can reduce things that drag the business down and enhance things that positively influence the business.

Many big businesses suffer from what they call, "analysis paralysis", which basically means they have gone too far. They have analysed everything and now have so much information that they can't make sense of any of it. Smaller businesses very often suffer from the reverse - "paralysis from lack of analysis"! Have a think about what information you have available in your business. How well do you really understand the cause and effect relationships?

But where do you start? Here's my suggestion: Take a key performance measure, one with strategic importance, and ask, "what would I have to do to make it better?" There may be several things you could do. Get information on what the current situation is for each of them. Then for each of those things, ask, "what would I have to do to make that better?" And keep on going through that cycle until you feel you have got somewhere close to root causes. Along the way you will have analysed your business performance and got valuable insight into the things you have to do to improve.

Here's an example: Let's say that in my business, staff costs represent 70% of the cost base. What would I have to do to make that better? Reduce headcount or reduce remuneration. Let's discount the latter for now. So we should analyse how our headcount is made up - by department, by grade, by location, etc. What would we have to do to reduce headcount in each of those categories? Reduce work or become more efficient. So let's analyse what work the people are doing and how efficient are they - what do they produce and how many do they produce per day, hour, week, month, whatever is appropriate? So with that information, what do we have to do to reduce work? Stop doing certain things - so what would be the impact? And what do we have to do to become more efficient? Do things quicker. So in order to see which things we need to do quicker, we need to analyse what activities have to be done to produce the outcome and how long each activity takes. Then we can look at the main activities and ask for each of them... you've guessed it! "What would we have to do to make that better (or quicker)?"

So to conclude, in order to manage business performance you need to measure it first. But you need to do more than that. You need to understand what the figures are telling you. And in order to understand, you need to analyse - financially, numerically and logically.

But one final word of caution - only measure things that are useful and you can act upon. If you find yourself regularly looking at figures that you do nothing with, then ask yourself what they are for... and if you can't find a satisfactory answer, STOP producing them and go and find some more useful analysis to look at!

In the next newsletter for new subscribers we'll look at your Finance resources - people, systems and processes. Are you getting the best out of them?

---

Until then, take care...

If at any stage you want to talk to us, we're quite happy to give you a call to talk more about your business and the challenges you face. And you may be eligible for a free Finance Strategy Review session. To set that up either email us at enquiries@charisfd.com, remembering to leave your phone number and email address; or go to our website and complete the contact form.

Thanks again for subscribing to Creative Finance & Management. We hope you find it helpful.

© Charis Business Consulting Limited 2009

This is the first in an 8-part series especially for new subscribers to the Creative Finance & Management email newsletter. Every week we will send you an article aimed at helping you think about a different aspect of the financial management of your business. This is in addition to the normal bi-weekly newsletter.

Why are we doing this? Well it's certainly not because we want you to be overloaded with spam! This email is NOT spam. You received it because you consciously signed up to receive our Creative Finance & Management newsletter. But, hey, we know that even some newsletters you consciously sign up to might as well be spam!

So why are we intent on sending you twelve emails in the first two months of your subscription? The answer is that I looked at the newsletters that were queued to go out and tried to think what it would be like to simply start getting them at a random point. It would feel like pretty random subject matter, without a framework or rationale. And I felt that it would probably be useful to give all new subscribers the same orientation to the way that Charis FD thinks about small business performance management. That way we can have confidence that all our subscribers have been given the benefit of foundational advice in all aspects of business performance management.

If you miss any of these articles, don't worry. They are on the Creative Finance & Management blog. Just look for the "New_Subscribers" tag.

These are the articles in the New Subscribers series:

1. The ingredients for success in Finance
2. Strategy and Planning
3. Business Change - implementing your strategic plans
4. Measurement and Management go together
5. Paralysis without analysis
6. Your Finance team - a valued asset
7. Stakeholder management - the importance of keeping people happy
8. Internal Control - 3 fallacies that add risk to your business

So, off we go...

---

The ingredients for success in Finance

First of all, let's recognise at the outset that there are many things that can be said about making business successful. That's why I'm confident that I am unlikely to run out of subjects for the Creative Finance & Management newsletter! But after careful reflection on all that I've learnt over my 18-year career in accounting, finance and business, I believe that the financial and performance elements boil down to seven or eight things.

Now I admit that there are academics out there, as well as big management consulting firms, who have researched and pondered and discussed and head-scratched over many years, and they have written big books on topics such as these. And they have probably come up with other ways of looking at things, perhaps even better. Who knows? I am just someone who has looked at what I have learnt over the last 18 years, in my training, courses I've attended, as well as reflections on the work I've done, and pulled it all together in a coherent way.

So "take it or leave it" is what I'm saying. I have no desire to be seen as any kind of finance and management guru. I simply want to help small businesses do things better.

So what are the ingredients for financial success? All I am going to do in this article is lay out the scenario and describe the model. In the next seven articles I will explain the important parts of the model and how applying these principles can help your business to become financial stronger and more successful.

The way I look at it is like a wheel, with a hub, and a couple of other things. I call it the Business Performance Management Wheel. If you go to the Our Services page of the Charis FD website you will see this illustrated and described. There are four points around the outside of the wheel:

Strategy and Planning

Actions and Change

Performance

Performance Reporting and Review

Those elements are linked with a directional arrow, indicating that actions and change result from strategy and planning, and contribute to business performance. Then you have to review the performance of the business through regular reporting in order to feedback into more strategy and planning.

In the middle of the wheel is "Finance", which should probably be more specifically "Finance Resources". Finance resources keep the wheel turning, providing information and control.

Around the outside of the wheel are two elements:

Stakeholder management; and

Risk management and compliance.

Those are two things that provide the environment for business performance management.

I should also say that there are other dimensions. So cash/working capital is a dimension that has different implications depending on which of the elements you are thinking about. Profit is another dimension. And Performance is a generic term that includes profit, but does not exclude any measure of success in your business.

Over the next few weeks in these introductory newsletters we will take each of the seven elements in turn and outline what the key elements are in getting the business performance management wheel turning smoothly for you.

First, next week, we will look at strategy and planning. Where does strategy come from and how do you decide what your strategy should be? If you don't have strategies for your business and plans for achieving your strategic objectives, then you are leaving too much to chance and your business will underperform.

Second, we will discuss business change. Sometimes it feels like there are so many options for useful projects you could do, or things you could change, but you can't do everything all at once. So how do you know which of the options will be best to choose?

In the third week we see that measurement and management go together. If you want to be able to manage your finances, or your business performance in general, then you have to regularly review measures of performance. This is an area many small businesses need help with.

Fourthly, we talk about the "paralysis without analysis". A lot of big companies talk about "analysis paralysis", meaning they have so many figures, so much management information, so much analysis of figures, that they don't know how to digest it all. Smaller businesses are often paralysed by the opposite problem. They don't know what to analyse and have very little management information and modelling. What things are most useful? Where should you start?

Fifth, we'll talk about finance resources. Finance resources is the term I use to encompass finance and accounting people, as well as systems, processes (and perhaps even cash!). Your finance resources are there to support you in managing your business to optimum performance, providing information and control, as well as expert advice. So that fifth article will tell you more about what you should expect from finance resources and how to get the most out of them.

Sixthly, stakeholder management gets a mention. Stakeholders are anyone who has any interest in your business. Shareholders and investors are the people we normally think of first, but the list gets longer the more you think about it. There are a host of people and entities that should get your attention as stakeholders in the business, and good relationships with them will smooth the way for growth.

Finally, we snooze through 700 words on internal control. I'm joking! It's very important! But a lot of people see internal control as something boring and tedious. So we'll consider three fallacies that add risk to your business in the realm of internal control.

---

Until next time...

If at any stage you want to talk to us, we're quite happy to give you a call to talk more about your business and the challenges you face. And you may be eligible for a free Finance Strategy Review session. To set that up either email us at enquiries@charisfd.com, remembering to leave your phone number and email address; or go to our website and complete the contact form.

Thanks again for subscribing to Creative Finance & Management. We hope you find it helpful.

© Charis Business Consulting Limited 2009